Can I Choose CrashFix Even if My Insurance Recommends Another Shop?

The simple answer is yes—you absolutely can choose CrashFix even when your insurance company recommends another shop. When your insurance company tells you to take your car to their preferred repair shop after a car accident, you might wonder if you have any choice in the matter. This fundamental consumer right is protected by law, and understanding your options can save you money while ensuring your vehicle receives the highest quality repairs. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll explore your legal protections, explain why insurance companies steer customers toward preferred shops, and demonstrate how choosing CrashFix provides better outcomes for your vehicle repaired after a car crash.
November 12, 2025

Your Right to Choose CrashFix Over Insurance-Recommended Shops

Many accident victims feel pressured by insurance adjusters to use specific repair shops within the insurer’s network. However, your legal right to select any certified collision repair facility remains intact, regardless of your insurance company’s preferences. CrashFix offers superior repair services that prioritize your vehicle’s safety and value over insurance company cost-cutting measures.

Yes, you have the legal right to choose CrashFix even when your insurance company recommends another repair shop. State law across the United States explicitly protects consumers’ rights to select any qualified repair facility for their vehicle damage. Your insurance policy covers repairs at any certified collision repair center, including CrashFix, and insurance companies cannot legally force you to use their preferred repair facilities.

These consumer protection laws emerged after decades of insurance industry practices that prioritized cost savings over repair quality and customer satisfaction.

When you file an insurance claim for car accidents, your insurer must honor your choice of repair facility as long as the shop meets basic licensing requirements. Insurance adjusters may suggest their preferred shops, but they cannot make coverage contingent on using those specific facilities. This legal protection ensures that your best interest, not the insurance company’s profit margins, guides your repair decisions.

The right to repair shop choice extends beyond simple preference—it represents your ability to prioritize quality, safety, and long-term vehicle value. Independent research shows that insurance companies often steer customers toward shops that agree to use aftermarket parts and streamlined repair processes that may compromise vehicle integrity.

Why Your Insurance Company Recommends Specific Shops

Insurance companies have contractual agreements with preferred shops that often prioritize cost savings over quality repairs. These direct repair program partnerships benefit insurers through reduced claim costs, faster processing times, and guaranteed pricing structures that may not serve your vehicle’s best interests.

Recommended repair shops typically agree to use aftermarket or recycled parts to reduce claim costs rather than original equipment manufacturer components. While aftermarket parts cost less initially, they may affect your vehicle’s safety systems, resale value, and long-term reliability. Insurance preferred shops often commit to specific pricing tiers that limit their ability to perform manufacturer-recommended repair procedures.

Insurance preferred shops may rush repairs to meet insurer timelines rather than quality standards demanded by modern vehicle complexity. Advanced driver assistance systems, hybrid powertrains, and sophisticated safety features require specialized diagnostic equipment and repair protocols that expedited repair processes may overlook.

Your insurer benefits financially from directing you to their network, not necessarily from the best repair outcome for your vehicle. Insurance companies negotiate volume discounts, preferred pricing, and cost-control measures with their direct repair program partners. These arrangements can save insurers significant money on claims while potentially compromising repair thoroughness and quality.

The claims process moves more smoothly for insurance companies when customers use preferred vendors, but this convenience often comes at the expense of comprehensive damage assessment and proper repair procedures. Independent shops like CrashFix maintain loyalty to customers rather than insurance company profit margins.

Benefits of Choosing CrashFix Over Insurance-Recommended Shops

CrashFix uses genuine OEM parts to ensure your vehicle maintains its original safety and performance standards after repair services. Original equipment manufacturer components provide exact fit, finish, and functionality that aftermarket alternatives cannot match. OEM parts preserve your vehicle’s structural integrity, crash protection, and warranty coverage that aftermarket substitutions may compromise.

Certified technicians at CrashFix follow manufacturer repair procedures rather than insurance company cost-cutting guidelines. Modern vehicles require specific repair sequences, torque specifications, and calibration procedures that ensure safety systems function properly after collision damage. Insurance-preferred shops may skip these critical steps to meet cost and timeline constraints imposed by insurers.

CrashFix provides lifetime warranties on repairs, offering long-term protection beyond typical insurance shop guarantees. This warranty coverage demonstrates confidence in repair quality and provides ongoing protection for your investment. Many insurance-preferred facilities offer limited warranties that may not cover comprehensive repair issues that emerge over time.

Advanced diagnostic equipment and repair technology at CrashFix ensure comprehensive damage assessment and proper restoration of vehicle systems. Modern collision repair requires sophisticated scanning tools, calibration equipment, and specialized training that many insurance-preferred shops lack. Proper diagnosis identifies hidden damage that rushed assessments may miss.

Personalized customer service at CrashFix focuses on your satisfaction rather than insurance company requirements. Independent repair shops prioritize customer relationships and reputation over volume processing demanded by insurance partnerships. This customer-first approach results in more thorough communication, better repair outcomes, and higher satisfaction levels.

What to Expect When Choosing CrashFix Against Insurance Recommendations

Your insurance company must still pay for repairs at CrashFix up to reasonable and customary rates established in your coverage area. Insurance policies obligate carriers to cover necessary repairs regardless of where you choose to have the work completed. Reasonable and customary rates reflect prevailing market prices for quality collision repair services.

Insurance adjusters may initially pushback but cannot deny coverage for using a non-preferred shop under state insurance regulations. Some adjusters may claim that using CrashFix will complicate the claims process or delay payment, but these assertions violate consumer protection laws in most jurisdictions.

CrashFix will work directly with your insurance company to handle estimates and payment processing throughout the entire process. Experienced collision repair facilities maintain established relationships with insurance carriers and understand the documentation requirements for smooth claim resolution. Professional shops like CrashFix handle insurance communications to minimize customer involvement.

You may need to be more involved in the claims process compared to using an insurance-preferred shop, particularly regarding repair authorization and supplemental damage discovery. Independent shops often identify additional damage during thorough inspections that requires insurance approval before proceeding. This extra diligence protects your vehicle’s integrity but may extend repair timelines.

Document all communications with your insurance company regarding your repair shop choice to protect your rights and ensure proper claim handling. Maintain records of conversations, email exchanges, and written correspondence that demonstrate your insurer’s response to your facility selection. This documentation becomes crucial if disputes arise during the repair process.

How to Handle Insurance Company Pressure

Insurance representatives may claim using CrashFix will delay your claim or cost you more money, but these tactics violate consumer protection laws. Steering practices that discourage customers from choosing their preferred repair facility are illegal in most states and subject to regulatory penalties.

Know that insurers cannot legally require multiple estimates or additional paperwork for choosing CrashFix over their preferred repair shops. Some insurance companies attempt to create bureaucratic obstacles that discourage customers from exercising their legal rights. These practices constitute unfair claims settlement behaviors prohibited by state insurance codes.

Request written confirmation of your right to choose any repair shop if your insurer applies pressure during the claims process. Insurance companies must acknowledge your legal rights in writing when challenged about steering practices. This documentation provides evidence of any subsequent retaliation or claim delays.

Contact your state insurance commissioner if your insurance company refuses to authorize repairs at CrashFix or engages in steering behavior. State regulators investigate consumer complaints about unfair claims practices and can impose sanctions on insurance companies that violate consumer protection laws. Filing complaints creates regulatory oversight that protects your rights and those of future accident victims.

Insurance companies may also suggest that their preferred shops offer better warranties or faster service, but these claims often misrepresent the superior quality and guarantees provided by independent facilities like CrashFix. Professional collision repair centers typically offer more comprehensive warranties and personalized service than high-volume insurance partners.

Steps to Take When Choosing CrashFix for Your Collision Repair

Notify your insurance company that you are selecting CrashFix as your preferred repair facility immediately after deciding to proceed with repairs. Clear communication establishes your choice and prevents insurance adjusters from making arrangements with their preferred vendors. Document this notification in writing to create a record of your decision.

Provide CrashFix contact information to your insurance adjuster for direct communication regarding damage assessment and repair authorization. Professional repair facilities prefer direct insurance contact to ensure accurate damage evaluation and appropriate repair scope approval. This direct communication streamlines the claims process while maintaining your choice of repair provider.

Schedule your vehicle inspection and damage assessment at CrashFix collision center as soon as possible after the car accident occurs. Prompt inspection allows for comprehensive damage evaluation and early identification of repair requirements that may not be immediately visible. Professional assessment ensures all necessary repairs are included in the initial estimate.

Review the repair estimate with CrashFix before submitting to your insurance company to understand the scope of work and repair procedures planned for your vehicle. Knowledgeable technicians can explain the repair process, parts requirements, and timeline expectations. This review ensures you understand what repairs are necessary and how they will be completed.

Keep detailed records of all repair documentation and insurance communications throughout the process to protect your interests and ensure proper claim resolution. Maintain copies of estimates, work orders, parts receipts, and correspondence with your insurance company. These records provide protection against disputes and ensure accountability from all parties involved.

Contact CrashFix for a free consultation if you need guidance navigating insurance company pressure or understanding your repair options. Experienced collision repair professionals can advise you on your rights, explain repair procedures, and advocate for proper claim handling. Professional guidance ensures you receive full compensation for necessary repairs while maintaining your choice of repair facility.

Conclusion

You absolutely can choose CrashFix even if your insurance recommends another shop—this is your legal right protected by state law across the country. Understanding this fundamental consumer protection empowers you to prioritize quality, safety, and long-term vehicle value over insurance company cost-cutting measures.

The benefits of choosing CrashFix over insurance-recommended facilities are clear: genuine OEM parts, manufacturer-approved repair procedures, comprehensive warranties, and customer-focused service that puts your needs first. While insurance companies may pressure you to use their preferred shops, remember that these recommendations primarily serve their financial interests, not your vehicle’s repair quality.

When you choose CrashFix, you’re selecting a repair partner committed to restoring your vehicle to pre-accident condition using the highest standards in the industry. Don’t let insurance company steering tactics compromise your vehicle’s safety, value, or your satisfaction with the repair process.

Take control of your collision repair experience by asserting your right to choose CrashFix. Document your communications with your insurance company, understand your legal protections, and prioritize quality repairs that will serve you well for years to come. Your vehicle deserves the best possible care after a car crash—and you have the legal right to ensure it receives exactly that.

Locations

Where are CrashFix locations

Conveniently located in Burbank and Los Angeles, CA, CrashFix serves all your collision repair needs throughout Los Angeles and Orange Counties. Visit us at either location for top-quality service, expert repairs, and a hassle-free experience, no matter where you are in the city.

Burbank, CA

1104 S. Victory Blvd., Burbank CA 91502
(818) 474-5250

Mon.-Fri. - 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Saturday - 9:00 AM - 1:00 PM
Sunday - Closed

24/7 Emergency service available
Vehicle Pickup and Delivery*

Los Angeles, CA

5252 W. 111th St., Los Angeles, CA 90045
(323) 999-2022

Mon.-Sun. - 8:00 AM - 8:00 PM

Open every day for your convenience.

24/7 Emergency service available
Vehicle Pickup and Delivery*
Areas we Serve

CrashFix Service Areas

From our convenient locations in Burbank and Los Angeles, we proudly serve clients throughout Los Angeles and Orange Counties. Our service area includes communities such as:

Get started

Get OEM Quality Repairs Today!

Choose your car manufacturer to learn more about our manufacturer-specific repair process and how we ensure factory-standard restoration for your vehicle.